top of page

CBT and Mindset: How to Change Your Thinking and Improve Performance in Sport

6 days ago
8 min read

Is Your Mindset Helping or Holding You Back?

Have you ever trained hard for something, felt prepared and confident, only to find that your mind seemed to get in the way when it mattered most?

Perhaps you've stepped onto a judo mat and worried about losing before the contest began. Maybe you've stood over a golf ball after a disappointing shot and struggled to concentrate on the next one. Or perhaps you've watched a rugby team lose confidence after making a mistake, allowing frustration to affect the next phase of play.


Judo players in competition

Anonymous Taken at Judo Junior British,, 2025


These experiences have something in common.

They demonstrate how the way we think about a situation can influence how we feel and what we do next.

Physical ability, technical skill and preparation are essential to sporting performance. However, our thoughts, emotions and responses can also influence how effectively we use those skills.

This is where Cognitive Behavioural Therapy (CBT) can help.

CBT offers practical ways to recognise unhelpful thinking patterns, challenge assumptions and develop more constructive responses to challenging situations.

The aim isn't to eliminate every negative thought or feel confident all the time. It's to learn how to respond more effectively when pressure, uncertainty or disappointment arises.

And these skills aren't limited to sport. They can also be applied to work, relationships and everyday challenges.


What Is Cognitive Behavioural Therapy (CBT)?

At Edinburgh CBT & Counselling Services Ltd, we work with the principal that CBT, is an established psychological approach that explores the relationship between our thoughts, emotions, physical sensations and behaviours.

A central principle of CBT is that the meaning we attach to an experience can influence how we respond to it.

Consider an athlete preparing for an important competition.

They might think:

"I'm going to make a mistake, and everyone will notice."

This thought could increase anxiety, create physical tension and make it harder to concentrate.

The athlete might then become hesitant or abandon the strategies they have practised.

Now imagine approaching the same situation with a different thought:

"I might make mistakes, but I can focus on my preparation and respond to what happens."

The competition hasn't changed. The athlete cannot guarantee the outcome. However, their interpretation of the situation has become more balanced.

That shift may help them approach the challenge more constructively.

CBT helps people identify these patterns and explore alternative ways of thinking and behaving.

It isn't about pretending that difficulties don't exist. It's about recognising that our first interpretation isn't always the only possible interpretation.


Understanding the Connection Between Thoughts, Feelings and Behaviour

One of the most useful CBT principles is recognising how thoughts, feelings and behaviours can influence one another.


To illustrate, imagine a golfer hits a poor shot.

The situation: The ball lands in the rough.

The thought: "I've ruined my round. I always do this."

The feeling: Frustration, disappointment and anxiety.

The physical response: Increased tension and difficulty relaxing.

The behaviour: The golfer rushes the next shot, becomes distracted or loses confidence in their decisions.


The second shot may then suffer, reinforcing the original belief that the round is going badly.

This is a pattern that can develop in many areas of life.

A single event triggers an interpretation, which influences our emotional and physical responses and affects what we do next.


CBT encourages us to recognise where we can interrupt this cycle.

The golfer might acknowledge the disappointment, challenge the belief that the entire round is ruined and return to their usual routine.

The original shot cannot be changed. However, the golfer can influence their response to it.


Why Does Mindset Matter in Sport?

Athletes spend hours developing strength, fitness, technique and tactical awareness.

But sporting situations often involve uncertainty.

You cannot control every decision an opponent makes. You cannot guarantee that every shot will go where you intend. You cannot prevent every mistake during a match.

When we become preoccupied with outcomes we cannot fully control, we can create additional psychological pressure.

Thoughts such as "I must win", "I cannot make a mistake" or "I need to prove myself" may increase anxiety and encourage unhelpful behaviours.

CBT principles can help athletes recognise these patterns and develop more realistic expectations.

Instead of trying to guarantee success, athletes can focus on the actions that give them the best opportunity to perform well.

These might include following a pre-performance routine, communicating with teammates, making good tactical decisions or responding constructively to setbacks.

The goal is to develop a mindset that supports performance without demanding perfection.


Professional golfer, focussed, having taken the perfect shot

Image by Chris Arjoon, Wix Media


Three Common Thinking Patterns That Can Affect Performance


1. All-or-Nothing Thinking

All-or-nothing thinking occurs when we view situations in extremes.

For example:

"If I don't win, I've failed."

"If I don't play perfectly, I'm not good enough."

This way of thinking leaves little room for progress, learning or recognising what went well.

A more balanced perspective might be:

"I want to win, but I can still learn and perform well even if the result isn't what I hoped for."

This doesn't mean lowering your ambitions. It means recognising that performance and development involve more than a single result.


2. Catastrophising

Catastrophising involves imagining the worst possible outcome and treating it as though it is likely to happen.

A judoka might think:

"If I lose this contest, my competition is ruined."

A golfer might think:

"If I miss this putt, I'll never recover my score."

A rugby player might think:

"If I miss this tackle, the whole team will blame me."

These thoughts can make an already challenging situation feel overwhelming.

A useful question is:

"What is the most realistic outcome, and how could I respond if things don't go as planned?"

This helps shift attention away from imagined disaster and towards practical coping.


3. Harsh Self-Criticism

Some athletes believe that criticising themselves is the best way to improve.

They may replay mistakes repeatedly, use negative language or believe they need to feel bad before they can do better.

However, harsh self-criticism can increase distress and make it harder to think clearly about what needs to change.

Constructive reflection is different.

Instead of saying, "I'm useless under pressure", an athlete might say, "I struggled to maintain my focus today. I can review what happened and practise a strategy for next time."

The second statement acknowledges the difficulty without turning it into a judgement about the person.


How Can CBT Help Develop a Stronger Mindset?

CBT isn't about replacing every negative thought with a positive one.

It's about learning to recognise thoughts, examine them carefully and respond in ways that are realistic and useful.

Here are five practical ways to begin.


1. Become Aware of Your Thoughts

The first step is noticing what happens inside your mind when you face a challenge.

Pay attention to your self-talk before competition, after mistakes or when you feel under pressure.

Ask yourself:

  • What am I telling myself?

  • What am I worried might happen?

  • Am I treating an assumption as a fact?

  • Is this thought helping me respond effectively?

You don't need to change everything immediately. Awareness provides a starting point.


2. Challenge the Evidence

When a thought feels convincing, pause and examine it.

Suppose you think, "I always make mistakes when the pressure is on."

Ask yourself whether this is genuinely true.

Have there been occasions when you managed pressure successfully? Are you focusing only on the mistakes and overlooking the times you performed well?

A more balanced thought might be:

"I sometimes struggle under pressure, but I've also handled difficult situations successfully. I can practise ways to improve."

This isn't artificial positivity. It's a more complete interpretation of the evidence.


3. Focus on What You Can Control

Many sporting outcomes depend on factors outside your control.

You cannot guarantee victory, prevent every error or determine exactly how an opponent will respond.

However, you can influence your preparation, effort, attention and decisions.

When you notice yourself worrying about the result, ask:

"What is one thing I can do right now that will help?"

This question can redirect your attention towards purposeful action.


4. Develop a Reset Routine

When something goes wrong, it helps to have a familiar process for moving forward.

A simple routine might involve:

Notice: Recognise that you're becoming frustrated or distracted.

Pause: Take a comfortable breath and give yourself a moment to respond.

Reframe: Identify a more balanced way to interpret what happened.

Refocus: Choose the next action that deserves your attention.

The details will differ between sports, but the underlying principle remains the same. You don't need to wait until you feel completely calm or confident before taking your next step.


5. Treat Mistakes as Information

Mistakes can provide useful feedback.

The important question is what you do with that information.

After a difficult performance, consider:

  • What went well?

  • What was challenging?

  • What was within my control?

  • What can I learn?

  • What will I practise next?

This approach encourages responsibility and improvement without unnecessary self-criticism.


CBT Across Different Sports

Different sports create different psychological challenges.

In judo, athletes may need to manage the anticipation of a one-to-one contest.

In golf, players must repeatedly reset their attention after individual shots.

In rugby, players need to manage personal reactions while communicating and working collectively.

Despite these differences, several CBT principles apply across all three.

Judo: Recognise competition anxiety, challenge thoughts about losing and focus on controllable actions.

Golf: Challenge perfectionism, learn from poor shots and return attention to the next decision.

Rugby: Respond to mistakes constructively, question unhelpful assumptions and maintain effective communication.

These approaches can be practised during training, not just when the pressure is highest.

Indeed, practising psychological skills in familiar situations may make them easier to apply when challenges arise.


Does a Strong Mindset Mean Never Feeling Nervous?

Absolutely not. Nervousness, disappointment and frustration are normal human responses.

A healthy mindset doesn't require you to feel positive all the time.

You can feel nervous and still compete effectively. You can feel disappointed and still learn. You can experience doubt and still make a useful decision.

The objective is not to eliminate uncomfortable emotions but to develop a more helpful relationship with them.

For example, instead of interpreting nervousness as proof that you're going to fail, you might recognise it as a sign that the situation matters to you.

You can acknowledge the feeling and still focus on your preparation.

This distinction is important because trying to suppress every uncomfortable thought or feeling can become another source of pressure.


Putting CBT Into Practice: A Simple Exercise

The next time you face a challenging situation, try completing these five steps.


Step 1: Describe the situation.

What happened? Stick to the facts rather than your interpretation.

Step 2: Identify your thoughts.

What did you tell yourself about the situation?

Step 3: Notice your response.

What emotions, physical sensations or behaviours followed?

Step 4: Consider an alternative perspective.

Is there a more balanced way to interpret what happened?

Step 5: Choose your next action.

What practical step can you take that aligns with your goals?

You can use this exercise after a sporting performance, a difficult conversation or a challenging day at work.

With practice, it can help you become more aware of the relationship between your thinking and your responses.


Your Mindset Is Something You Can Develop

Developing a healthier mindset isn't about becoming a different person or eliminating every doubt.

It's about understanding your thinking patterns, recognising when they aren't helping and practising alternative ways of responding.

CBT provides a structured approach to this process. Read more in our blog posts.

Whether you're preparing for a judo competition, working towards a better golf round, playing in a rugby team or navigating challenges in everyday life, the opportunity is similar.

You may not be able to control every situation, but you can learn to influence how you interpret it and what you do next. You don't have to think positively all the time. You can learn to think more helpfully when it matters most.


Ready to Develop Your Mindset?

Start by noticing one thought that appears when you're under pressure.

Ask yourself whether it's accurate, whether it's helping you and what a more balanced response might look like.

Small changes in awareness and behaviour can provide a starting point for meaningful progress. Book a session with us to explore further.
































 
 
 

Comments

Rated 0 out of 5 stars.
No ratings yet

Add a rating
IMG_5310.JPG

Welcome to my blog!

It's more of a communal meeting space than a blog.

 

My goal is to use my expertise to cover the topics that are most important to you.

 

So let’s be in constant conversation as we work to understand our bodies and ease our minds.

Post Archive 

Tags

14 South Trinity Road, Edinburgh, EH5 3NR

36A Broughton St, EH1 3SB

86 Causewayside, EH91PY

Edinburgh

​

  • https://www.facebook.com/edinburghcbt/
  • Instagram
  • https://www.linkedin.com/in/jacqueline-thompson-275655218
  • X

Inclusion Policy:
Edinburgh CBT is an LGBT+, Gender, Religion, Disability, Race and Neurodiversity affirming and validating psychotherapy practice.

Sign up to receive our blog posts.

Thanks for subscribing!

​© 2022 Edinburgh CBT. Site by LoudLocal

bottom of page